Home » Manhattan vs Old Fashioned

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Welcome to the Manhattan vs Old Fashioned showdown.

In the world of classic whiskey cocktails, two iconic drinks often come to mind: the Manhattan and the Old Fashioned. These two legendary concoctions have graced the lips of whiskey lovers for generations, each with its own unique flavor profile and dedicated following. But what sets these two drinks apart, and how can you decide which one best suits your taste buds? In this article, we’ll explore the differences between the Manhattan and the Old Fashioned, touching on their ingredients, taste, and history. As you delve into the world of whiskey, be sure to check out our guide on what an Old Fashioned tastes like to get a better understanding of its flavor nuances.

Manhattan drink vs Old Fashioned drink
Manhattan vs Old Fashioned

Manhattan vs Old Fashioned

The Manhattan and the Old Fashioned are two of the most classic cocktails in the world. They are both made with whiskey, bitters, and a sweetener, but they have a few key differences.

The Manhattan is made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters. It is typically served in a stemmed glass and garnished with a cherry. The Old Fashioned is made with bourbon whiskey, bitters, and sugar. It is typically served in a rocks glass and garnished with an orange peel.

The Manhattan is a more complex cocktail than the Old Fashioned. The sweet vermouth adds a sweetness and complexity that the Old Fashioned does not have. The Old Fashioned is a simpler cocktail, but it is no less delicious. The whiskey and bitters come together to create a rich and flavorful drink.

The Manhattan is a more versatile cocktail than the Old Fashioned. It can be enjoyed on its own or as part of a cocktail hour spread. The Old Fashioned is a more traditional cocktail and is best enjoyed on its own.

Manhattan vs Old Fashioned
Manhattan vs Old Fashioned

Old Fashioned and Manhattan Ingredients

One of the most significant differences between a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned lies in their ingredients. A Manhattan is a more straightforward mix, typically consisting of whiskey (usually rye), sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters. It’s garnished with a maraschino cherry and sometimes an orange twist. On the other hand, an Old Fashioned is made with whiskey (often bourbon), sugar or simple syrup, Angostura bitters, a splash of water, and a twist of orange or lemon peel for garnish.

Taste of the Old Fashioned and Manhattan Drinks

When it comes to taste, both cocktails are whiskey-forward but have distinct flavor profiles. The Manhattan boasts a slightly sweeter taste, thanks to the addition of sweet vermouth, which adds a rich, complex depth to the drink. The Old Fashioned

offers a more robust and straightforward whiskey experience, with the sugar and bitters serving to enhance and highlight the whiskey’s natural flavors. The citrus twist in both drinks adds a subtle brightness, with the Old Fashioned leaning more towards a caramelized citrus note due to the muddled peel.

History

The origins of these two classic cocktails can be traced back to the 19th century. The Old Fashioned is believed to have been created in the early 1800s in Louisville, Kentucky, and later popularized at the Waldorf Astoria in New York City. The Manhattan, on the other hand, was invented in the 1860s at the Manhattan Club in New York City. Although the precise details of their creation are murky, both cocktails have stood the test of time and remain popular choices for whiskey aficionados.

Choosing Your Drink

Remember that quality ingredients can make all the difference in whichever cocktail you choose. For example, when choosing the perfect whiskey for a Manhattan, consult our guide on the best whiskey for a Manhattan. Similarly, selecting a quality whiskey and using fresh ingredients will significantly impact the final result when crafting an Old Fashioned.

Tips for making a good Manhattan at home

  • Use high-quality ingredients, such as rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters.
  • Chill the glass before adding the ingredients.
  • Stir the ingredients gently to combine.
  • Garnish with a cherry.

Tips for making a good Old Fashioned at home

  • Use high-quality ingredients, such as bourbon whiskey, bitters, and sugar.
  • Muddle the sugar and bitters together to release their flavors.
  • Add the whiskey and stir until combined.
  • Garnish with an orange peel.

What is an Old Fashioned?

Mix It Up

Don’t be afraid to get creative and experiment with different whiskey types, bitters, and garnishes to discover your perfect combination. For instance, try swapping out the traditional rye whiskey in a Manhattan with bourbon, or using a different type of bitters in your Old Fashioned. You might be surprised by the delightful variations you can create with just a few simple tweaks.

In conclusion, both the Manhattan and the Old Fashioned have their unique charm, and choosing between them is ultimately a matter of personal taste. As you explore the world of whiskey cocktails, be sure to check out our guide on how to order an Old Fashioned to ensure a top-notch experience every time. So, whether you prefer the sweet complexity of a Manhattan or the bold, straightforward flavors of an Old Fashioned, one thing is for sure: these classic whiskey cocktails are here to stay. Cheers to discovering your perfect whiskey libation!

Image credit

What is a Manhattan?

A Manhattan is a classic cocktail made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters. It is typically served in a stemmed glass and garnished with a cherry.

What is an Old Fashioned?

An Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail made with bourbon whiskey, bitters, and sugar. It is typically served in a rocks glass and garnished with an orange peel.

What are the main differences between a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned?

The main differences between a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned are the type of whiskey used, the type of vermouth used, and the garnish. A Manhattan is made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters. An Old Fashioned is made with bourbon whiskey, bitters, and sugar. A Manhattan is typically served in a stemmed glass and garnished with a cherry. An Old Fashioned is typically served in a rocks glass and garnished with an orange peel

Which cocktail is better?

This is a matter of personal preference. Some people prefer the sweeter taste of the Manhattan, while others prefer the more complex flavor of the Old Fashioned. Ultimately, the best way to decide is to try both and see which one you like better.

How do I make a Manhattan at home?

To make a Manhattan at home, you will need the following ingredients:
2 ounces rye whiskey
1 ounce sweet vermouth
2 dashes Angostura bitters
1 cherry
Instructions:
Fill a mixing glass with ice.
Add the whiskey, vermouth, and bitters.
Stir until well-chilled.
Strain into a chilled stemmed glass.
Garnish with a cherry.

How do I make an Old Fashioned at home?

To make an Old Fashioned at home, you will need the following ingredients:
2 ounces bourbon whiskey
1 sugar cube
2 dashes Angostura bitters
1 orange peel
Instructions:
Muddle the sugar cube and bitters in a rocks glass.
Add the whiskey and ice.
Stir until well-chilled.
Garnish with an orange peel.